Travel DestinationsUnderrated US Destination: Affordable Island Getaway with Beautiful Beaches, a Perfect Alternative...

Underrated US Destination: Affordable Island Getaway with Beautiful Beaches, a Perfect Alternative to Martha’s Vineyard and Montauk

AMERICANS have been given a new vacation destination that doesn’t break the bank and is just as good as tourist favorites. Enter the charming St. Simons Island in Georgia, which has recently been ranked the topmost underrated spot within the United States.

5

The Island of Martha’s Vineyard may have found a new, less crowded rivalCredit: Getty – Contributor


5

St. Simons Island in Glynn County, Georgia, has been ranked the topmost underrated destination in the USCredit: Alamy

St. Simons Island offers travelers a budget-friendly alternative to the likes of Martha’s Vineyard in Massachusetts and Montauk in New York. While the latter two have become synonymous with luxury and high expenses, St. Simons presents a refreshing option that’s not only easier on the wallet but also less crowded, allowing for a more tranquil getaway.

According to travel experts from U.S. News, St. Simons Island snagged the coveted title for the best underrated travel destination in the US. The rankings were derived from a combination of expert opinions, traveler votes, available activities, and crowdedness, underscoring what makes this hidden gem so appealing.

Located off the Georgia coast, St. Simons Island boasts a rich history dating back to the Civil War. As the largest barrier island in the Golden Isles, it’s characterized by stunning salt marshes, sandy beaches, and the occasional sighting of migrating whales for curious nature lovers.

“It is often overlooked by out-of-state beachgoers,” the travel experts explained, noting how many travelers flock to Florida and South Carolina instead. They added, “This dreamy barrier island is home to stately live oaks, dune-lined beaches, maritime forests, and quaint shopping villages, lending it a peaceful, laid-back atmosphere even during peak season.”

The island is an oasis for those seeking an array of activities, encompassing museums, golf courses, and various water sports, including fishing and biking. In terms of value, St. Simons Island also excels over its competitors, scoring an impressive 72 out of 100 on the World Travel Index, compared to Martha’s Vineyard’s 66. These scores are calculated based on a variety of aspects such as activities, safety, and travel costs.


Beach with vegetation and ocean in the background.

5

St. Simons has ranked higher than Martha’s Vineyard due to cost, traveler reviews, and things to do thereCredit: Alamy

Gay Head Lighthouse at sunset.

5

A trip to Martha’s Vineyard could easily cost thousands of dollars for just a weekend, compared to a few hundred for St. Simons, travelers have saidCredit: Alamy

The cost disparity is notable. A vacation rental in Martha’s Vineyard can set you back between $350 and $400 per night, while you can enjoy a similar accommodation in St. Simons Island for only $200 to $250 on average. Restaurant meals also favor St. Simons for budget-conscious travelers, although bar prices remain relatively consistent between both locales.

On platforms like Reddit, travelers looking to attend glamorous events in Montauk have been warned to “be prepared to pay at least $3k” for a weekend. In stark contrast, spending an average of $2,954 will cover you for a whole week in St. Simons, equating to around $211 per day, according to BudgetYourTrip.com.

If you’re not entirely sold on island vibes, the runner-up on the U.S. News list of top underrated destinations offers an exciting alternative. The Sawtooth National Recreation Area in Idaho came in second, showcasing breathtaking scenery with over 750,000 acres of protected land. With more than 700 miles of hiking trails, hikers can delight in the massive mountains and alpine lakes.

Door County, Wisconsin, nabbed third place. It offers a winter wonderland adventure for those who enjoy snowfall and winter activities like skiing, snowshoeing, and exploring frozen lakes.


Happy senior couple walking through an airport, pulling luggage.

5

Travelers looking for a new holiday destination should explore outside of the usual tourist locations to save money and find peace and quiet (stock)Credit: Getty

New updates

More From UrbanEdge

Sustainable Travel in Japan: Explore Mottainai Culture, Eco-Friendly Transportation, and Responsible Tourism Practices

Eco-Friendly Travel to Japan: Discover Mottainai Culture, Green Transportation,...

Exciting Travel Destinations to Discover in 2026

Top Travel Destinations to Explore in 2026 As 2026 unfolds,...

9 Top Family-Friendly All-Inclusive Resorts in the Caribbean

The Ultimate Guide to Family-Friendly All-Inclusive Resorts in the...

Thrill Seekers: Top Hiking and Outdoor Adventures in South America

Published on January 4, 2026 A trip to South...

Ananta Hotels Unveils Ananta Express in Katra

Ananta Hotels & Resorts has...

Ryanair Unveils Top 5 Must-Visit Destinations for 2026: Your Next Adventure Awaits!

Ryanair Reveals Top 5 Destinations for 2026: Must-Visit Cities...